Skip to content
Guide · Cold calling

Cold Calling Tips: Five Mistakes Founders Make

The cold calling tips that matter most are about what happens before and after the call: who is on the list, whether you have a real reason to call, and how many times you try. It takes an average of 8 attempts to reach a prospect (Cognism, 2025). Most founders stop at three.

Founders hate cold calling for a rational reason: done without structure, it fails almost every time, and each failure is personal. The fix is not more nerve. It is finding which of these five mistakes is yours.

Five cold calling mistakes founders make

1. Calling the wrong list

You call whoever you can find a number for.

A great call to the wrong company is still a wasted call. The 2.3% average success rate (Cognism, 2025) includes every unresearched list in the sample.

Where it gets fixed: THE LIST, the course on building the list that builds your pipeline.

2. Going in cold

You dial without knowing what they sell, what changed, or who owns the problem.

You sound like every other caller. Referencing shared context in the opener raises the odds of a meeting by 70% (LinkedIn Sales Solutions, cited by Cognism, 2025).

Where it gets fixed: The Recon. For a head start, the free Thread Finder finds your connection into an account.

3. Winging the first ten seconds

They pick up and you make it up as you go.

You freeze, or you ramble, and the prospect decides you are a telemarketer before you reach the point.

Where it gets fixed: First Contact. See three openers to drop and one that works.

4. Pitching when you should be asking

You get thirty seconds and spend all of them on your product.

The prospect learns about you. You learn nothing about them, so there is no reason for a second call.

Where it gets fixed: The Trusted Advisor: diagnose before you prescribe.

5. Quitting after three attempts

Two calls and a voicemail, then you move on.

It takes an average of 8 attempts to reach a prospect (Cognism, 2025). Stopping at three gives up most of the list before anyone answers.

Where it gets fixed: The Cadence: follow-up systems that keep deals from going cold.

One fix you can make today

Before your next call, write down one sentence that starts "The reason I'm calling is" and finish it with something true about that prospect. If you cannot finish the sentence, you are not ready to dial that number.

What the numbers say

Cold calling benchmarks

  • Average success rate per call: 2.3% in 2025 (Cognism, 2025).
  • Cognism's own team, using targeted data and structured calls: 6.7% in the same report. Roughly triple the average, from process alone.
  • 57% of C-level and VP buyers prefer to be contacted by phone over any other channel (RAIN Group, cited by Cognism, 2025).

The gap between average and good is structure, not talent. Sources and the full picture: Cold Calling in 2026: What the Data Says.

Cold calling training, if you want the words

This page tells you what is going wrong. The courses give you the words to fix it, with live coaching twice a week on your real calls inside The Foundation OS. Not sure where your leak is? The Blueprint is the full first course, free, and it ends by pointing you at the course that fixes yours. Also read what a good cold call script sounds like.

Cold calling FAQ

How do I get over the fear of cold calling?

Replace the fear with a plan. Most of the dread comes from not knowing what to say when someone answers. Decide your first line, your reason for calling and your next step before you dial. Structure does what confidence cannot.

How many times should you call a prospect?

Plan for at least eight attempts. It takes an average of 8 call attempts to reach a prospect (Cognism, 2025). Most sellers stop far earlier, which is why a scheduled cadence beats enthusiasm.

Is cold calling worth a founder's time?

Yes, as one channel in a structured motion. 57% of C-level and VP buyers prefer the phone over any other channel (RAIN Group, cited by Cognism, 2025). A founder calling a researched list with a stated reason is the person the buyer most wants to hear from.

Sources

  1. Cognism, "The Top Cold Calling Success Rates for 2026 Explained," published March 2025. cognism.com/blog/cold-calling-success-rates
  2. Gong and LinkedIn Sales Solutions research on call openers, as cited in the Cognism analysis above.
  3. Full figures and context: Cold Calling in 2026: What the Data Says.
Daniel Shand
Daniel Shand

Founder of THE FOUNDATION. 20+ years selling B2B, from cold call to closed contract. $100M+ in career sales and dozens of pipelines built from $0 to $1M+. Runs two live coaching sessions every week inside The Foundation OS.

Cold calling is a craft. Crafts are taught.

The Blueprint is free: the whole sales system in plain terms. No trial, no card, just the work.

Start The Blueprint, free